We analyzed 296 active 5-bedroom Airbnb listings in Scarborough, Pickering, and Ajax to understand what drives revenue for larger vacation-style properties in the GTA's eastern corridor.
The results reveal opportunities that most hosts are missing - particularly around amenities like pools and hot tubs, pet policies, and guest capacity optimization.
This analysis covers 342 5-bedroom listings in the Scarborough, Pickering, and Ajax area from January 2026, of which 296 had sufficient revenue data for analysis. Revenue estimates are monthly figures based on trailing performance data.
Key Findings at a Glance
Revenue Overview: The Full Picture
Five-bedroom properties in this market show dramatic revenue variation - more so than smaller units. The gap between top and bottom performers is substantial.
The significant gap between mean and median indicates a small number of highly optimized properties are pulling the average up. Most hosts aren't capturing the full potential of their 5-bedroom listings.
Revenue Distribution
The top 10% earn 19x more than the bottom 10%. Understanding what separates them is key to maximizing your revenue.
Amenities That Pay Off Big
For 5-bedroom properties targeting families and groups, certain amenities have an outsized impact on revenue. Here's what the data shows:
Pool: The Biggest Revenue Driver
Having a pool nearly doubles your revenue potential for 5-bedroom properties.
While only 17 of 296 listings have pools, they dramatically outperform. Groups traveling together for vacations, reunions, or celebrations actively seek pool properties and will pay a significant premium.
Hot Tub: Strong Returns
Hot tubs deliver a 65% revenue boost, making them one of the best investments for 5-bedroom properties.
Hot tubs signal a "vacation experience" that justifies premium pricing. They're particularly attractive for winter bookings when pools aren't usable.
Pets: A Surprising Revenue Booster
Unlike smaller units where pets often correlate with lower revenue, 5-bedroom properties that allow pets earn 34% more.
Why Pets Work for Larger Properties
- Families traveling with dogs need larger spaces
- Less competition - most hosts don't allow pets
- Groups pay premium rates for pet-friendly options
- Larger properties can better absorb any wear
Guest Capacity: Maximize It
For 5-bedroom properties, maximizing guest capacity directly correlates with revenue.
Properties that can accommodate 13+ guests earn nearly double what those limited to 6 guests earn. Groups booking 5-bedroom properties are typically large - make sure you can serve them.
Bathroom Count Matters
For larger properties, bathroom access is critical. More bathrooms = higher revenue.
| Bathrooms | Avg Revenue | Listings |
|---|---|---|
| 4.5+ bathrooms | $3,339 | 26 |
| 3.5-4 bathrooms | $2,897 | 102 |
| 2.5-3 bathrooms | $2,605 | 113 |
| 1-2 bathrooms | $2,119 | 55 |
Properties with 4.5+ bathrooms earn 58% more than those with only 1-2 bathrooms. For groups of 10-14, adequate bathroom access is a dealbreaker.
Reviews: The Compounding Effect
Review count is one of the strongest predictors of revenue for 5-bedroom properties.
Listings with 100+ reviews earn nearly 5x more than new listings with no reviews. For large group bookings, trust and social proof are paramount.
The Rating Sweet Spot
Similar to smaller properties, we see that 4.7-4.89 rated listings actually outperform 4.9-5.0 listings.
Listings in the 4.7-4.89 range typically have more reviews and longer track records. Perfect ratings often come from newer listings that haven't yet built booking momentum.
The Guest Favorite Badge: 81% Premium
Airbnb's Guest Favorite badge has an enormous impact on 5-bedroom property revenue.
For groups booking expensive 5-bedroom properties, the Guest Favorite badge provides crucial trust signals. Over a third of listings (103 of 296) have earned this badge.
Dynamic Pricing: Still Important
Dynamic pricing continues to drive results for larger properties, though the effect is less dramatic than for smaller units.
| Dynamic Pricing Level | Avg Revenue | Listings |
|---|---|---|
| High | $3,572 | 39 |
| Moderate | $3,030 | 64 |
| Low | $2,417 | 65 |
| None | $2,366 | 121 |
High-intensity dynamic pricing delivers a 51% boost over static pricing. Tools like PriceLabs or Wheelhouse help capture premium rates during high-demand periods (holidays, summer, long weekends).
Economic Category Impact
Positioning matters. Upscale properties dramatically outperform budget options.
Upscale positioning earns nearly 3x more than economy positioning. For 5-bedroom properties, investing in quality finishes, professional photos, and premium amenities pays dividends.
Cancellation Policy: Be Strategic
Established properties with strict cancellation policies significantly outperform those with flexible policies.
| Cancellation Policy | Avg Revenue | Listings |
|---|---|---|
| Strict | $3,996 | 20 |
| Firm | $2,950 | 119 |
| Limited | $2,493 | 30 |
| Moderate | $2,408 | 44 |
| Flexible | $2,208 | 80 |
Strict cancellation policies correlate with 81% higher revenue compared to flexible policies. As you build reviews and demand, tightening your policy protects against costly last-minute cancellations.
Actionable Tips to Increase Your Revenue
Based on this data, here are the highest-impact changes for 5-bedroom property hosts:
Add a Hot Tub (or Pool if Possible)
These amenities drive the biggest revenue premiums: pools (+96%) and hot tubs (+65%). For group properties, they transform a "place to stay" into a "vacation experience."
Allow Pets
Unlike smaller properties, 5-bedroom listings that allow pets earn 34% more. Large groups with pets have few options and will pay premium rates for pet-friendly accommodations.
Maximize Guest Capacity
Properties sleeping 13+ guests earn nearly double those limited to 6. Add quality sofa beds, bunk beds, or futons to increase capacity without sacrificing comfort.
Add Bathrooms
Properties with 4.5+ bathrooms earn 58% more than those with 1-2. If you're renovating, prioritize adding bathrooms to serve larger groups.
Pursue the Guest Favorite Badge
The 81% revenue premium is substantial. Focus on response time (under 1 hour), avoid cancellations, and resolve guest issues immediately.
Position as Upscale
Upscale properties earn 3x more than economy listings. Invest in professional photography, quality furnishings, and premium amenities. Price accordingly.
Frequently Asked Questions
What's the average monthly revenue for a 5-bedroom Airbnb in Scarborough/Pickering?
Based on our analysis of 296 active listings, the median monthly revenue is $1,984. The mean is higher at $2,680 due to top performers earning over $15,000/month. Revenue varies significantly based on amenities, guest capacity, and management practices.
Does having a pool significantly increase Airbnb revenue?
Yes, dramatically. Our data shows listings with pools earn an average of $4,972/month compared to $2,540/month without - a 96% premium. For 5-bedroom properties targeting families and groups, a pool is one of the highest-impact amenities you can offer.
Should I allow pets in my 5-bedroom Airbnb?
Interestingly, yes. Unlike smaller units, 5-bedroom listings that allow pets earn 34% more ($3,256/month vs $2,424/month). Larger groups traveling with pets are willing to pay premium rates for pet-friendly accommodations, and there's less competition in this niche.
How much does a hot tub add to revenue?
Hot tubs provide a 65% revenue boost on average. Listings with hot tubs earn $4,284/month compared to $2,600/month without. For vacation-style properties in Scarborough, Pickering, and Ajax, hot tubs are a strong investment.
Does the Guest Favorite badge matter for larger properties?
Absolutely. Listings with the Guest Favorite badge earn 81% more ($3,782/month vs $2,092/month). The badge signals quality to groups booking larger properties, where trust and reliability are even more important.
How many bathrooms should a 5-bedroom Airbnb have?
More is better. Properties with 4.5+ bathrooms earn $3,339/month on average, while those with only 1-2 bathrooms earn $2,119/month. For group accommodations, bathroom access is a major factor in guest satisfaction and pricing power.
What's the ideal guest capacity for a 5-bedroom listing?
Maximizing capacity pays off. Properties accommodating 13+ guests earn $3,608/month on average, while those limited to 6 or fewer guests earn only $1,844/month. Groups are willing to pay premium rates for properties that fit everyone comfortably.
Does cancellation policy affect revenue for larger properties?
Yes. Listings with Strict cancellation policies earn $3,996/month on average, compared to $2,208/month for Flexible policies - an 81% difference. Established properties with strong reviews can implement stricter policies without losing bookings.
Want to Maximize Your 5-Bedroom Revenue?
Nurture specializes in managing larger properties in Scarborough, Pickering, and Ajax. We use data-driven strategies to help hosts earn 30-100% more from their 5-bedroom listings.
Get Your Free Estimate